I heard this while speaking with my friend Mark Levy, who heard it from some branding guy, he couldn’t remember whom. “Positioning is dead,” the guy said. Since both Mark and I are positioning people this was of major interest.

He said that positioning was dead because the people, the users, the community… they were creating the positions of companies by participating in Web 2.0. He believed that companies’ positions were defined by what was being said about them in the infosphere.

This is total nonsense. While Web 2.0 gives people a voice and amplifies the conversation, you have to ask where the conversation comes from in the first place.

Look–most people, bloggers included, want to be lead. They want to be told what to think about and how to think. Then they can react and respond, but not until then. It’s very rare that people initiate the conversation. Those who do are called “thought leaders,” everyone else is part of the crowd.

Positioning is all about framing a context that defines what people need to think about. Positioning is about providing the seeds that ultimately flower into conversation. Reasonable people take the seeds and help them germinate. Unreasonable people create the seeds. Good positioning unreasonably tells people what to think in the first place.

Web 2.0 is a fabulous development in how people and businesses communicate. It’s like going from a one-way street to multi-lane boulevard. Just don’t get deluded into seeing this as creativity. Most of the time it’s just traffic.